Pain or Pleasure? Better Questions About What Motivates You

Two gravel paths branch into a fir forest beside a wooden sign.

Based on Tim Brownson’s original work

Written by Andy Hood, drawing on an original article by Tim Brownson, who founded A Daring Adventure.

It is tempting to give every habit a tidy label. You are a “towards” person or an “away from” person; you need a certain number of repetitions before an idea finally gets through. Once named, the machinery supposedly explains you.

I would use these ideas as questions, not as a personality operating manual.

When actions and values disagree

Cognitive dissonance describes discomfort associated with inconsistent beliefs or with a mismatch between beliefs and behaviour. If health matters to you and you keep postponing care, there may be a tension worth exploring.

That does not mean a coach should shame you into acting. There may be money worries, fear, practical barriers or competing responsibilities. “What makes this hard?” is a more useful starting point than “You must not care enough.”

Notice the generalisation

“I always get this wrong” deserves a closer look. Always? What happened on the last few occasions? Is there a difference between a skill you have not learnt and an identity you have assigned yourself?

Generalisation can be useful; we do not need to relearn every ordinary task from scratch. The trouble comes when a convenient shortcut becomes a verdict that rules out other possibilities.

There is no need to explain that through fixed NLP categories or a magic number of things the conscious mind can hold. Ask for the actual examples.

What would count as convincing?

If you are considering an unfamiliar idea, identify the evidence you need. A demonstration? A reliable comparison? An opportunity to try it safely? Hearing a claim repeatedly is not proof of its truth.

Likewise, a company's willingness to spend money on advertising does not establish that every campaign works or that its message is sound.

What are you moving towards, or away from?

Perhaps you want a new role because the work interests you. Perhaps you want to leave because the current job is wearing you down. Both can be true.

Consider what you hope to gain, what you hope to avoid and who else is affected. Then ask whether the proposed action serves those purposes.

A label may begin a conversation. It should not be allowed to finish one.

Sources and further reading

If you found this article helpful, you might also enjoy From Values to Action.

Andy Hood smiling in a checked shirt

The Adventure Edit

Join The Adventure Edit, my newsletter for ideas about making more deliberate choices. As a welcome, I’ll send you Does the life you’ve built still fit?, a free PDF workbook to help you notice what’s worth keeping and what you might try next.

Confirm your email to receive the workbook, then two follow-ups about using it and coaching. After that, occasional newsletters and coaching updates. Unsubscribe any time and keep the workbook. How I use your information.

ADA | The Adventure Edit and workbook | Consent v2026-11-15